Sunday, March 11, 2012

FINAL BP68

I've been talking on twitter plenty about this bracket, and between all of my blog posts the past few days, I think I've made my reasoning pretty clear.

For the last at-large bid, I dislike the fact that I ended up agreeing with most everybody else on the past few teams. The one team that I have in which doesn't deserve to be there is Drexel. The "eye test" is nonsense - you're supposed to get in the bracket for having a better resume than the teams that are out. Drexel played a joke of a schedule, and the Selection Committee has always punished that. Drexel would have the weakest schedule of any at-large team ever. If they get in then Seth Greenberg is going to flip out. Weak schedule was always the argument against Virginia Tech... so, why does Drexel get a pass?

But there's no question Drexel is the media darling, and anybody who does believe in that "eye test" nonsense is going to want to pick them. Plus, I'm very curious to see how the Selection Committee responds to the rapid increase in social media this year. There's no question that Drexel is the "people's choice". Will the Selection Committee be swayed?

Of the teams I have out of the bracket, Tennessee is the most intriguing. If we're going to throw away the early part of the season because of a missed player for Drexel, then we should do it for Tennessee also. They went 10-6 in the SEC and had four wins against the RPI Top 50 over that stretch. They have a better overall resume than USC did last year when the Trojans got a pass for adding a player midseason. That said, Jio Fontan was more important to USC than Jarnell Stokes is to Tennessee, so I don't think they're going to get quite the same pass. So I have them out.

As for the 1 seeds, I think Kentucky, Syracuse and North Carolina are safe. If I had my druthers, I'd pick Michigan State for that last 1 seed. But I don't think the difference between them and Missouri is large enough for the fact that the Selection Committee has a history of not giving the Big Ten tournament champion much of a bump for winning that last game. The reality is that they already have their brackets drawn up. They'll have a contingency bracket in case a bubble team is playing in the game, but I don't think they'll do the same just to decide a 1 seed vs a 2 seed. So I'm giving the edge to Missouri, though you can definitely make a good argument for either Michigan State or Kansas (who had a clearly better resume than Missouri during the regular season before falling to Baylor in the Big 12 tournament semis).

I'll have more thoughts on the bracket selection after it's announced. I'll also start breaking down the bracket immediately to help you get ready for your own bracket contests. So come on back soon.

Here we go:

1. Kentucky
1. Syracuse
1. North Carolina
1. MISSOURI (BIG 12)

2. Ohio State
2. Kansas
2. MICHIGAN STATE (BIG TEN)
2. Duke

3. Baylor
3. Michigan
3. LOUISVILLE (BIG EAST)
3. Marquette

4. Wisconsin
4. Georgetown
4. Indiana
4. FLORIDA STATE (ACC)

5. NEW MEXICO (MWC)
5. MEMPHIS (CONFERENCE USA)
5. San Diego State
5. Cincinnati

6. ST. MARY'S (WCC)
6. UNLV
6. VANDERBILT (SEC)
6. Wichita State

7. Temple
7. Gonzaga
7. MURRAY STATE (OVC)
7. Notre Dame

8. Florida
8. CREIGHTON (MVC)
8. Iowa State
8. Purdue

9. Kansas State
9. Alabama
9. UConn
9. St. Louis

10. HARVARD (IVY)
10. Texas
10. BYU
10. VCU (COLONIAL)

11. California
11. Virginia
11. West Virginia
11. Southern Miss

12. Colorado State
12. COLORADO (PAC-12)
12. LONG BEACH STATE (BIG WEST)
12. Xavier
12. South Florida

13. NC State
13. Drexel
13. ST. BONAVENTURE (ATLANTIC TEN)
13. OHIO (MAC)
13. SOUTH DAKOTA STATE (SUMMIT)

14. BELMONT (ATLANTIC SUN)
14. DAVIDSON (SOUTHERN)
14. MONTANA (BIG SKY)
14. NEW MEXICO STATE (WAC)

15. LOYOLA-MARYLAND (MAAC)
15. LEHIGH (PATRIOT)
15. LIU (NEC)
15. DETROIT (HORIZON)

16. NORFOLK STATE (MEAC)
16. LAMAR (SOUTHLAND)
16. UNC-ASHEVILLE (BIG SOUTH)
16. VERMONT (AMERICA EAST)
16. WESTERN KENTUCKY (SUN BELT)
16. MISSISSIPPI VALLEY STATE (SWAC)

If I missed somebody on the bubble, these are the most likely teams:
Miami (Fl), Seton Hall, Northwestern, Oregon, Washington, Mississippi State, Tennessee, Oral Roberts

Other more distant possibilities - that could possibly get a bid, but probably shouldn't:
Marshall, Iona, Akron, Arizona, Ole Miss, Middle Tennessee, Nevada

11 comments:

Sean said...

Why does it say Ohio State won the Big ten tourney? Michigan State won, and that should give them the last #1 seed, or at least a seeding above Ohio State.

Sean said...

I agree with the teams you have in the tournament, my only difference is that I have Miami in and Colorado State out based on virtually nothing haha. Also, if it were up to me the #1 seeds would be Kentucky, Syracuse, Kansas, and Michigan State. #2 would be Missouri, UNC, Ohio State, and Duke. What the selection committee decides however is always a bit puzzling, so we'll see.

Jeff said...

Sorry about the typo on the Big Ten champ. Fixed it now.

And yes, I agree that if it were up to me I'd make Michigan State the fourth #1 instead of Missouri.

I just don't think the Selection Committee is going to take the Big Ten title game into account this year.

David Mann said...

-30-4 (17-4 in the Big 12), including wins over Kansas, Baylor,(3), Iowa State (2), Notre Dame, Texas (3), California, and Illinois (while they were still an elite team.)
-3-1 against teams ranked in the Top 10
-4-1 against the Top 15.
-Ended the season on a five game winning streak.
-Won their Big 12 Tournament games by an average of 15.7 points.

And a 7, yes 7 loss Big 10 team is a 1, and we're a 2. Completely, completely unfair. The Big 10 isn't that much better than the Big 12.

Jeff said...

You realize that two of those seven losses were against North Carolina and Duke, right?

Losses are not all equal.

David Mann said...

Well, whatever. It will be proven right or wrong on the court now. I'm just glad that we are at least in the same regional as Michigan State.

Jeff said...

Missouri got a huge break from the Selection Committee. Their path is easier than Michigan State's path. Be thankful you didn't get that 1 seed.

Sean Finley said...

Memphis being an 8 seed is sad. They deserved better. I was worried about them getting a 7 instead of the 6 they deserve and playing a 2 seed 2nd round, now they have to play a 1 seed 2nd round...what a joke.
I also was high on Uconn, but going against Kentucky 2nd round if they beat iowa state is going to make it extremely tough to pick them as a sleeper.
I think Syracuse Ohio State and Florida State have very easy paths to the Sweet 16, and should be very happy with their bracket.
North Carolina was the weakest 1 seed in my opinion, but their road to the elite 8 is a cake walk. I think USF is the only team that could challenge UNC on their road to the elite 8, and I can't see USF even making it that far...so UNC should be elite 8 bound for sure.

Anonymous said...

What is your opinion on Iona getting in? Deserving or no?

Anonymous said...

I think Creighton-UNC would be a fascinating game. Former teammates Doug McDermott and Harrison Barnes playing for the first time against each other. John Henson's health is a big question mark, since he would likely be matched up against Doug McDermott. If Henson's playing, if's a great matchup of Henson, the DPOY in the ACC and Doug McDermott, the POY of the Valley. Otherwise, North Carolina holds the advantage over Creighton at the rest of the positions, though I would argue that Creighton's bench is deeper in terms of players than North Carolina's. If Henson can't play, I would at least consider taking Creighton. If he will, I don't think it will be close. Your thoughts Jeff?

Jim Squire said...

It's a joke to rip a mid-major's schedule and not rip high majors for refusing to play teams like that.